Muddy mobile graphics waters dead ahead
April 19, 2012 // Rick Merritt
Tim Leland, the guy I think of as Mr. Graphics at Qualcomm, pulled me aside as I was leaving the Linley Tech Mobile Conference yesterday. He wanted to make sure I understood that a core is not a core when it comes to graphics.
When it comes to mobile SoCs generally chips with two CPU cores are better than those with one, four cores are better than two, and so on. But not so with the GPU.
What Qualcomm calls a graphics core is different from what Nvidia or someone else calls a GPU core, he said. So when Huawei boasted at Mobile World Congress this year its K3V2 mobile SoC with 16 Vivante GPU cores will blow away the competition, well, take it with a grain of salt, Leland said.
The problem is there’s no clean way to compare graphics performance which is rapidly becoming the center of competition in mobile systems. Indeed the graphics part of mobile SoCs is growing faster than any other part of the chip. Apple’s latest iPad showed that mobile design these days is all about the graphics and what they can deliver in display and photo resolution.
So what’s an OEM to do? Hire a grad student to sort through the dozen or so relevant graphics benchmarks, run them on all the key chips and do a multivariate analysis of the results. That’s Tim’s advice anyway.
I translate it this way: Duck! I see a few years of marketing head spin dead ahead as we try to sort out who’s leading the manic mobile market in its pursuit of triangles per second--which by the way is not a good single benchmark either!
Unfortunately the darkness gets even deeper. The next big thing in graphics is using these massively parallel chips to handle naturally parallel applications of all sorts such as media processing. The reason you can do this is that the GPU “cores” are made up of sometimes thousands of sub-cores, but let’s not go there.
Luckily, programmers do not have to understand all the details of the hundreds of sub-cores inside a graphics core. They can just use an API such as OpenCL from Khronos, or Cuda from Nvidia or AMP from Microsoft or River Trail from Intel or Aparapi from AMD or Renderscript from Google or OpenACC which is related to OpenMP which is…wait a minute, I’m lost!
Stirring the pot, OpenCL itself is splitting into a high-level API for programmers and a low level one for chip designers. This makes sense, but adds to the seeming confusion for the outsider. Oh, and the core OpenCL spec will probably see a new rev in 2013.
At the Linley Tech conference, API guru Neil Trevett showed one packed slide that tried to lay out all the options in APIs for doing general-purpose processing on a GPU. It was messy.
Neil Trevett's partial map of the messy GPGPU terrain.
By the way, now that the OpenGL ES 2.0 standard for accelerating mobile graphics is being used everywhere, it’s time for version 3.0. Expect whatever features this new rev defines to become the new battleground in mobile GPU cores. Trevett would only say the 3.0 update is “coming soon.”
Microsoft could get ahead of the mobile graphics game because Windows 8 on ARM (now called Windows RT) supports the relatively advanced and mature DirectX APIs Microsoft uses on PCs. Only trouble is none of the three mobile SoCs that Microsoft supports with Win RT support DX11. Instead, they support, through a kludge more generally called “a shim” the older DX9 APIs.
There’s a chicken-and-egg problem here. Mobile chip makers won’t want to spend the energy and gates to support DX11 until there are apps that take advantage of it—and vice versa. Poor Microsoft, just can’t seem to get ahead of the Apple and Android pack in mobile!
Meanwhile, as if reality itself isn’t weird enough, augmented reality is coming.
Khronos is helping create some of the silicon plumbing for the merger of the physical and the digital/virtual worlds with work on its media streaming API and a new API for sensor fusion coming later this year. The display technology for powering augmented reality products like Google’s Project Glass, however, is probably still five years away, said Trevett.
So I feel I really need to understand graphics better. But Qualcomm’s Leland also reminded me why it’s hard to get a good graphics education.
Graphics companies have been slapped with suits citing trade journal articles where their execs described the allegedly infringing features in their chips. It takes big money to make such suits go away. That explains why I almost never get pitched about in-depth technical briefings on graphics.
Hydrogen power enters the call center
May 23, 2013
A UK startup has had significant success with its hydrogen-powered power system as an uninterruptible power supply for call ...
Brussels Calling: Qualcomm wins in a wasteful industry
Europe in 10 billion € bid to boost chip industry
Nujira surpasses own world record for ET PA linearity
Silica moves to fast lane in Europe's LED market
Intel's new CEO shakes things up
May 23, 2013
Newly minted Intel Corp. CEO Brian Krzanich wasted little time putting his stamp on the company he has worked for for more ...
Wide-angle lens is less than 3mm high for the same diameter
Low-power wireless projected to make waves in remote controls according to IMS Research
Intel pushes for more research beyond 10-nm
InterviewSilica moves to fast lane in Europe's LED market
In the booming market for LED lighting, electronics distributor Silica intends to lead the pack by offering technological excellence at application level. The company is currently planning to offer tailor-made ...
Filter WizardCheck out the Filter Wizard Series of articles by Filter Guru Kendall Castor-Perry which provide invaluable practical Analog Design guidelines.
Linear video channel
READER OFFERRead more
The development platform for i.MX 6Quad from element14 (built to the Freescale SABRE Lite design) is an evaluation platform featuring the powerful i.MX 6Q, a multimedia application processor with Quad ARM Cortex-A9 cores at 1.2 GHz from Freescale Semiconductor.
This month, Freescale and element14 are giving away five such platforms, worth £128.06 each, for EETimes Europe's readers to win. The platform helps evaluate the rich set of peripherals and includes a 10/100/Gb Ethernet port, SATA-II, HDMI v1.4, LVDS, parallel RGB interface, touch screen interface, analog headphone/microphone, micro TF and SD card interface, USB, serial port, JTAG, camera interface, and input keys for Android.
And the winners are...
In our previous reader offer, Pico Technology was giving away one of its recently launched PicoScope 3207B, a 2-channel USB 3.0 oscilloscope worth 1451 Euros. Lucky winner Mr L. Sanchez-Gonzalez from Spain should be receiving his PicoScope 3207B soon. Let's wish them some interesting findings with his projects.
December 15, 2011 | Texas instruments | 222901974
Unique Ser/Des technology supports encrypted video and audio content with full duplex bi-directional control channel over a single wire interface.